Best Crib Mattress Reviews

Did you know that your child is most likely going to spend 60% of her first 5 years in her crib? And that the type of mattress your baby sleeps on affects how she sleeps?

It is easy to get your baby on a sleep pattern if her mattress is super comfy. She will wake up in the morning all cheerful, with a smile on her face. To boot, you get to enjoy a good night’s sleep as well since she slept through the night.

So now that you are on the hunt for the best crib mattress for your baby, you have most likely encountered several crib mattresses. The trick is determining which mattress is perfect for your little one. That’s why we are going to help you decide with this review of Amazon top 10 crib mattresses.

So let’s dive in!

#1 Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

Coming in at #1 is this crib mattress from Storkcraft. With close to a century of experience in manufacturing high-quality mattresses for babies from infants to toddlers, Storkcraft has perfected the art. This experience and expertise shine through in this Graco Crib Mattress.

Designed with baby’s comfort and safety in mind, it is a great choice for your baby’s crib. It’s made with breathable foam with a water-resistant layer which ensures that your baby stays cozy, dry and clean in her crib.

It is also constructed with anti-microbial and anti-static materials and is free from lead and phthalates which protects your baby from exposure to toxic chemicals. Five inches thick, this Graco mattress is very comfortable for your baby. It is easy to clean, and since it is lightweight, it is no hassle changing the sheets. Measuring 52 x 27.6 x 5, Graco Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress can fit in any standard full-size crib. It is covered by a 6-year warranty.


  • Made from breathable foam
  • Has a water-resistant lining
  • Easy to clean
  • It is free from phthalates and lead


  • Some users reported that the mattress failed to expand


#2 Dream On Me Spring Mattress

If you want a healthy, comfortable and safe sleep environment for your baby, you should consider this crib mattress from Dream On Me. It is a spring-coil based mattress that provides maximum support and comfort for your baby so he can enjoy a good night’s sleep.

The Dream On Me Spring Mattress feature lock-stitched binding that keeps the edges of the mattress from unraveling. And thanks to the perimeter border wires, the mattress will retain its original shape, and the corners, sides, and edges remain as firm. You won’t have to worry about the mattress sagging which is not only uncomfortable for your baby but also a safety hazard.

Keeping the baby’s crib clean is very important, and this mattress allows that and even makes it easy. The mattress has airflow pockets that prevent germs from getting into the mattress which helps it stay fresh and clean. It also features an insulation system, hypo-allergenic and waterproofing components keeps the mattress germ-free.

The stain-resistant, laminated waterproof covers prevent liquids from leaking inside and protects against mildew, mold, and odors. Thanks to these awesome features, you keep the baby’s bedding clean and smelling fresh.

Dream On Me Spring Mattress is made from quality materials that adhere to federal flammability standards. It is phthalates and lead-free, and comes with a 10-year limited warranty.


  • Stain-resistant and easy to clean
  • Waterproof laminate to provide double leakage protection and mite and bacterial protection
  • Free from PVC, vinyl, polyurethane or other harmful chemicals
  • Very affordable


  • Durability issues
  • Makes a loud noise when the baby moves
  • Too soft for infants


#3 Milliard Crib Mattress(100% Cotton Cover)

If you want your baby to have longer nights, you need a mattress that provides a soft but sturdy support and is super comfortable. This Milliard Crib Mattress certainly fits the bill and is a great choice for any parent who wants a comfortable mattress for their baby.

Forget the uncomfortable, cheap and low-quality synthetic blends that some crib mattresses use, this Millard crib mattress is made from Millard’s unique premium foam that provides a perfect combination of support and comfort.

The Millard Foam is CertiPUR certified and combines hypoallergenic and anti-microbial components to deliver a crib mattress, that is resistant to allergens, bacteria, dust mites and mold. So if your baby has allergy or asthma, this mattress is a perfect choice. Millard’s unique technology also provides for maximum airflow, weight distribution and regulates sleep temperature. This ensures that your baby breathes fresh air and has a restful sleep.

The mattress has a removable cover that is waterproof on the top and sides, which allows heat and air to ventilate the bottom. It also prevents leakage and seepage and provides for an easy clean-up. This lightweight mattress is 5 inches thick and is sturdy but soft enough for an infant. The Milliard Crib Mattress is safe for your child as it uses an inner fiberglass lining that is free from chemicals and toxins and meets all fire regulations.


  • Made from Millard’s unique high-quality foam
  • Resistant to allergens, bacteria, dust mites and mold
  • Easy to clean up


  • The waterproof cover falls apart if washed every day


#4 Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib Mattress

The Delta Children Twinkle Stars Mattress is an extra firm mattress weighing 12.3 lb. The high-density foam is made from firm thermo-bonded polyester fiber which offers enhanced support and comfort for your baby while ensuring minimum sagging. The finished square corners create a secure fit inside the crib and leave no gaps or spaces that your child can slip into.

The mattress is made of high-quality materials free from lead, phthalates and toxic fire retardants. It has been tested by CPSIA and exceeds flammability safety standards. It is also GreenGuard Gold certified which means the mattress has low chemical emissions. This is not only great for your baby but for the environment as well.

Thanks to the laminated waterproof vinyl cover, it is super easy to clean it. You can just wipe it down if you want a quick clean-up. While some crib mattresses can be too soft or too firm for an infant to comfortably sleep in, the Delta Children Twinkle Stars Mattress has a perfect balance between softness and firmness to provide just the right firmness while still being soft. This makes it a great choice for someone with an infant. What’s more, this crib mattress is very versatile and can fit inside a standard crib as it measures 52 x 27.5 x 6 inches.

Since this crib mattress was constructed with quality materials, it is durable and your baby can grow in it. You definitely get value for your money with this crib mattress. It is made in the USA and is covered by a 7-year limited warranty.


  • It is GREENGUARD Gold certified
  • American made using firm thermo-bonded polyester for maximum support
  • Free from lead, phthalates and toxic fire retardants
  • Finished square corners create a secure fit inside the crib


  • Some users complained of indentation marks
  • Some noise complaints when the baby rolls


#5 Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

Safety 1st has over 30 years experience making home safety products and have established itself as the leader in child safety. They even came up with the little Baby On Board sign. They continue to produce innovative products with high safety standards and the Heavenly Dreams mattress is one of their best crib mattresses. Made with high-density, thermo-bonded and polyester fibers, this mattress is designed to provide the right amount of support for your baby.

Despite being high-density, this crib mattress is lightweight, which makes it easy to maneuver and flip. The sleeping surface is 100% vinyl that is hypoallergenic and free of phthalates and lead. It is also resistant to odors so you can be sure your baby’s mattress with smell fresh even after long use. The mattress cover is stain and water-resistant, so no need to worry about spills. Clean up is very easy, you can quickly wipe it down.

Heavenly Dreams mattress is GreenGuard Gold certified for low chemical emissions and meets federal flammability regulations. You can have peace of mind knowing your baby is tucked in safe. It is a 2017 Women’s Choice Award as America’s most recommended brand for crib and toddler mattress. Safety 1st provides a 5-year limited warranty for this mattress.


  • It is firm and provides good support to the child
  • It is easy to wipe down and keep clean
  • GreenGuard Gold certified for low chemical emissions
  • Meets federal regulations for flammability
  • Has 5-year warranty


  • Some users complain of tearing and cracking after about a year of use
  • Some also reported the mattress as too small to fit a standard-sized crib


#6 Milliard Crib Mattress(Hypoallergenic + Waterproof Encasement)

The Dual Comfort System mattress by Millard comprises a supportive foam layer and contouring memory layer that combine to offer maximum support for your baby’s back and neck. This mattress is not only perfect for your infant but for your toddler as well. While a soft mattress may be great for a toddler, many parents prefer a firmer mattress for newborns since they require maximum support for the spine and neck.

Thanks to their experience manufacturing crib mattresses, Millard understands this. So they came up with this Dual Comfort system that features a form-fitting and comfy layer for toddlers on one side and a firmer, supportive layer for infants on the other. This double-sided mattress is a perfect combination of comfort and safety. Your newborn can grow with this crib mattress and once he can easily roll over and lift his head, you can simply flip the mattress over and let him enjoy the comfort offered by body contouring memory foam on the toddler’s side.

The mattress cover is made up of 100% natural cotton that is breathable, soft to the touch and is hypoallergenic. It features an anti-slip layer that keeps the cover in place. The cover is precisely fitted, so you don’t have to worry about it bunching or wrinkling as your baby turns. It is also water-resistant and machine washable, so no need to worry about spills or nighttime accidents.

The CertiPUR certified polyurethane foam in the Dual Comfort System mattress is a plush platform and extremely comfortable for your baby to sleep in. It is also very safe and durable and can fit in any standard-sized crib and toddler bed.


  • Double-sided mattress for toddlers and infants
  • The cover is 100% cotton, breathable, water-resistant and machine washable
  • Made of supportive foam layer and contouring memory layer for maximum comfort and support


  • Some users claimed the mattress is too soft for an infant
  • Complaints of failure to expand


#7 Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Crib Mattress

The Little Dreamer crib mattress is made with medical grade non-toxic nylon that is waterproof and has a durable stretch knit fabric. It has extra tight sewn seams to prevent tearing and unraveling. This mattress features a dual side sleep system that uses CertiPUR certified, extra firm plant-based foam layer for your infant’s side, and a soft plush side that is firm enough for your toddler.

The Little Dreamer crib mattress is safe for your baby as it is certified to be free from flame-retardant and toxic chemicals. It is GreenGuard certified for very low emissions and has SafeSewn Seams that protects against bed bugs and dust mites. So you need not worry about your little one’s safety.  The mattress cover is hypoallergenic, waterproof, antimicrobial and resistant to odors. It can be cleaned easily with a damp sponge. It comes with a lifetime warranty on manufacturing defects which is a big plus.


  • Made of high-quality medical-grade foam
  • Designed for newborns and toddlers
  • It is lightweight and easily flappable
  • Has a lifetime warranty on manufacturing defects


  • There were few complaints about the mattress sinking in the middle after a while


#8 Colgate Eco Classica III Crib mattress

This crib mattress is among the best on the market, thanks to amazing features that provide superb comfort and safety to your child. Featuring an orthopedic style dual zone design, with Eco memory foam infused with plant oils, this mattress is designed for babies and toddlers.

One side has a firm layer of foam that provides a firm, flat and even surface for the baby. This ensures that the baby has all the support she needs for her growing body. A firm surface also strengthens the baby’s muscles, as it allows her to turn, push up and eventually stand up. It also ensures the baby doesn’t sink into the crib mattress, which can hinder her breathing. Once your baby becomes a toddler, you can flip to the softer side as it provides greater comfort and support toddlers need.

The mattress cover is made of 100% organic cotton, that is waterproof and PVC free. The cover is washable and easy to clean up. The inverted seams give the mattress a sleek appearance and will look great in the crib. The foam used is high-quality and eco-friendly as it’s made with non-food plant oils. The EcoClassica III crib mattress passes federal flammability and chemical composition requirements and has been certified by GreenGuard to have very low harmful air emissions.


  • Lightweight and easy to flip over
  • Dual firmness for babies and toddlers
  • Extremely low harmful emissions
  • Made with high-quality memory foam


  • There is no mention of a warranty
  • The few complaints from users refer to lack of labels on the mattress


#9 Sealy Baby Crib Mattress

This Sealy baby mattress has a hospital-grade cover and binding, which is the best materials for maintaining a sanitary and healthy sleeping environment for your baby. Interwoven heat-tempered steel coils are used to provide firm orthopedic support for your baby’s back and neck. This mattress has an anti-sag technology that distributes the baby’s weight evenly, which is not only very comfortable for the little one but also ensures posture support.

This high-coil count mattress has border rods around the mattress that keep the edges, corners and sides firm. This provides for a secure fit into the crib and ensures the mattress maintains its original shape. Beneath the waterproof cover, two non-allergenic foam cushioning wrap around the mattress and offers your baby a very luxurious feel and comfort so he can have a restful sleep.

The firm and flat, even sleeping surface makes this crib mattress ideal for newborns. And thanks to the hospital-grade waterproof cover, cleaning up is a breeze. This Sealy baby mattress is a Gold certification from GreenGuard for ultra-low emissions.


  • Provides a soft but firm support for your baby
  • Has hospital-grade waterproof surface
  • Has high-coil count which provides maximum support
  • GreenGuard Gold certified


  • Has no airflow feature
  • Makes crinkly noise when the baby moves
  • Some users complained of indentation in the middle


#10 LA Baby Portable/Mini Crib Mattress


Won’t it be great if you could carry your baby’s crib mattress whenever you are traveling? Thanks to this LA baby waterproof mattress, you now can. At 2 inches thick, it weighs a mere 2 pounds, so you can easily roll it up and carry it with you next time you are going out of town with your baby.

It is meant to be used as a replacement mattress, so if you are waiting on your baby’s crib mattress to be delivered, you can use this mattress meanwhile. Measuring 38 x 24 x 2 inches, it can fit any standard-size portable crib and small and compact cribs.

Made with high-density polyfiber, the LA baby mattress is very comfy for your baby. It has a tear-resistant, waterproof, hypoallergenic and non-toxic vinyl cover. It also has a dust mite barrier and is anti-microbial. You can use mild soap and water to keep this crib mattress clean since it is stain resistant and waterproof. It comes with a 1-year warranty.


  • It is lightweight and compact which is great for traveling
  • Made with density polyfiber which is very comfortable for your baby
  • Easy to clean
  • Comes with a 1-year warranty


  • If you want a thicker mattress for your baby, this is not a great choice


Buying Guide

Now that we have looked at the top 10 crib mattresses on Amazon, next is what you should consider when buying one for your baby. While all these mattresses do the same thing, they have different features. Here are three things you should look for:


This is one of the most important aspects of a crib mattress. When you tuck in your baby you want to know that she is going to be safe in the crib. Mattresses made with poor quality materials can tear or unravel, which is a choking hazard as your baby can swallow a piece.


The best mattress for a newborn is one with a firm surface. This is because it provides a flat and even surface which infants need. A baby can sink into a soft mattress, which could restrict airflow inside the crib and the baby can find it hard to breathe.

Side spaces

Look for a mattress that fits snugly into the crib. Your little one can easily get trapped in the space between the crib and mattress. Check the space using two fingers; if it’s more, consider getting another mattress as this is dangerous for the baby.


As a parent, you want the best for your child. You want her to be happy, sleep well and comfortably, and be safe in her crib. One way to do this is by having the best crib mattress. With the right mattress, your baby will have a comfortable and restful sleep.